North Wind elk study keeps client in compliance
Tim Lingle has a few undead elk on his hands.
“We get a lot of false notifications that elk have died,” Lingle explains over the phone from his office in Pinedale, Wyo. As the Wyoming operations manager for CIRI subsidiary North Wind Resource Consulting, it’s his job to keep tabs on the 46 GPS-collared elk that roam the mountains near Denbury Resources’ gas processing facility.
The collars the elk wear include a motion-sensor device, similar in shape to a ball bearing. If the sensor doesn’t move for six hours, it triggers an automatic email to Lingle’s inbox. Lingle thinks some of the motion sensors must have gotten stuck, and that’s why he’s getting notifications that some elk are dead.
Data downloaded from a satellite feed tells a different story, though. “The data shows these elk are moving hundreds of yards,” he explains. “The one I just checked, over the last four days, she probably covered about 30 miles.”
Knowing where and how far these elk roam is part of an ongoing study, sanctioned by the Wyoming Game and Fish Department (WGFD), that North Wind is running to keep its client, Denbury Resources, in compliance with the WGFD and the U.S. Bureau of Land Management (BLM). In 2008, when the plant was owned by Cimarex Energy, the company agreed to conduct a study to determine whether the elk were being displaced from their native winter range. In case of displacement, Denbury has set up a mitigation fund to pay for habitat improvements.
So far, though, those improvements haven’t been necessary. “There’s been little avoidance of the plant area to this point,” reports Lingle. Thanks to the data he’s gathered, he’s been able to dispel assumptions made by local authorities. For instance, two years ago, BLM claimed the elk were avoiding their winter habitat because of the plant. But, says Lingle, “At that time, there were no elk at all in the winter area. The data showed the elk were at 10,000 feet. It was mid-winter, but we had no snow whatsoever; the elk had no reason to move off their summer range, and the data showed that.”
To collect the data, North Wind hired a crew that specializes in aerial services for wildlife capture. Perched in the doorway of a low-flying helicopter, crew members shoot a net at the targeted elk, then quickly land. Once an elk is netted, workers hobble and blindfold the animal to keep it calm while they place the collar and take a blood sample for brucellosis testing by the WGFD.
“Other captures use a tranquilizer, and that’s really bad for the animal,” Lingle explains. “It suppresses their heart rate and their ability to thermo-regulate, so they’ll actually overheat, even though it’s twenty below. So the blindfold is how these guys handle the animals.”
Once the collar is on, the elk is released. This is the only contact the capture crew will have with the animal; the collars are timed to drop off automatically in May 2017, at which point Lingle or his colleagues will retrieve them.
Sometimes, though, it’s not that straightforward. Local hunters often end up with a collar or two in their possession. Most collars are returned to WGFD, but some end up in strange, and sometimes unsavory, places.
“A horn hunter found four of our collars before we could get to them, and they ended up in the dump,” recalls Lingle. “So we spent an afternoon digging through the garbage. They’d pull out bales of garbage, and those would immediately burst, and we’d dig—we couldn’t get a signal, otherwise we would have gone right to the collars. We only ever found one.”
Much of Lingle’s work consists of interacting with the public, explaining the purpose of the study or fielding phone calls anytime Denbury starts “flaring,” or burning off excess gas. The rest of his work, he says, is “number crunching and slicing up data.” And the data tells him that local elk, initially spooked by the flares, soon grew used to them and returned to their habitat. The data tells him that, while the goal is for 40 percent of the elk to stay within the crucial winter range around the facility, 56 percent are currently using the area.
But common sense tells him that dead elk don’t wander. So he’ll reprogram the motion sensors in the collars via satellite to alert him if an elk doesn’t move for eight hours, instead of six. Then he’ll download more data, mapping out where the elk have traveled so he can report back to WGFD and BLM. “We’re just trying to provide sound scientific data to both our customer and the agencies,” he says.